A counter-offer deserves careful thought, but a higher salary does not automatically solve the reasons you wanted to leave. Compare what your current firm is actually changing with what the new role offers. Neither staying nor leaving is the right answer in every case.
Start with the reasons you looked elsewhere
Write down your original reasons before discussing the revised package. Was it pay, an unmanageable caseload, limited progression, the commute, working arrangements or the type of work? Then mark which of those issues the counter-offer addresses.
If you wanted broader work or better supervision, extra salary alone may leave the central problem unchanged. If pay was the main concern and you otherwise like the role, a properly documented adjustment may deserve serious consideration.
Compare the two roles on the same basis
- Pay: distinguish guaranteed salary from discretionary bonuses and future reviews.
- Work: compare the caseload, billing expectations, support and responsibilities.
- Progression: ask what a proposed promotion means in practice, who approves it and when it would take effect.
- Working pattern: clarify office attendance, hours and any flexibility important to you.
- Management: consider whether you can have a constructive discussion about the reasons you considered leaving.
Ask for specific commitments
“We will review things soon” is different from a written salary adjustment with an effective date. Ask the firm to set out what it is offering, including any conditions. Consider how realistic a promised change is if it depends on recruiting another person or reorganising the department.
There is no reliable universal percentage that predicts whether you will regret accepting a counter-offer. Your decision needs to reflect the actual roles and the credibility of the commitments.
Handle the decision professionally
Ask for a reasonable opportunity to compare the offers and agree when you will respond. Keep the prospective employer and recruiter informed. Do not assume that the new vacancy will remain available if you turn it down and change your mind later.
If you have already accepted an offer, submitted notice or signed documents, check your position before changing course. Take appropriate advice where contractual obligations are unclear.
Choose the role you want to do
Ask yourself: if both firms paid the same, which role would I prefer? That question will not settle every decision, but it can reveal whether salary has distracted you from a more important difference.
Explore our legal career articles and salary guidance. If you want to explore a move, register with Ten Percent Legal Recruitment and explain the work and conditions you are seeking.
